If I understand your narrative, I make the following inferences:
--you looked at a neglected 1983 Boston Whaler OUTRAGE 18 boat left without attention for 11-years outdoors
--you found that in the central cockpit deck, if your remove the circular deck pry-out access plates there was wet foam
The construction of a 1983 Boston Whaler OUTRAGE 18 provides for a central cavity or depression or molded space in the cockpit area into which an aluminum fuel tank is installed. The aluminum fuel tank is mechanically fastened in place, and the remaining space between the fuel tank and the molded hull is then filled with a low-density foam.
It is often seen that water on the deck on a Boston Whaler boat like this OUTRAGE 18 can flow downward from the deck into this central fuel tank cavity and lay atop the tank and the foam surround. It is also seen that the water can migrate into the foam and flow downward, collecting in the bottom of the cavity, creating perpetually wet foam which is in contact with the aluminum fuel tank.
The result of water collecting in the central fuel tank cavity is a slight increase in the hull weight from the retained water, which is usually not particularly significant. The water stops at the gel coat layer of the actual hull. It does not penetrate into the inner hull.
The wet foam, however, can cause corrosion of the aluminum fuel tank, leading to perforations in the tank walls and leaking of fuel from the tank. It is also seen that the plywood reinforcement for the deck molding that covers the fuel tank cavity is affected by the water, and the plywood often rots, losing strength.
Refurbishment of the central fuel tank cavity deck cover, the cavity itself, and replacement of a fuel tank are all major projects. For refurbishment of a deck and cleaning of the cavity, see
Under-deck Repairs On a 1985 OUTRAGE 22by Jeff Rohlfing
http://continuouswave.com/whaler/refere ... store.htmlThis article shows repairs on a larger boat, but the construction is the same as on an OUTRAGE 18. Review this lengthy, detailed, illustrated, two-part article to gain an appreciation of the project. The article does not show replacement of the fuel tank. This is a separate and similarly arduous task, which is probably going to cost over $1,500.
Returning to your narrative, it is impossible to know the condition of the deck, the cavity, and the fuel tank on the Boston Whaler OUTRAGE 18 hull you have described in your narrative. Further investigation is needed.
It is important to realize that presence of some wet foam in the top layer of foam under the central deck that surrounds the fuel tank is by no means any sort of indication of INGRESS OF WATER INTO THE ENTIRE HULL. Advice to abandon all hope for the particular hull in which you found some wet foam on the top of the tank cavity is not necessary bad advice, but it should not be construed to mean the entire hull is wet. Most likely the hull is not wet, and there is just some wet foam around the fuel tank.
As for advice on buying this particular boat, I cannot offer any. Only you have seen it. Only you know how much work you want to put into refurbishment of any defects. Only you know the price range you can pay for an OUTRAGE 18.
You should also know that having water in the foam surrounding the fuel tank is by no means seen on every Boston Whaler boat. It is not unusual to find water in that area, particularly for a neglected hull that has not been used for 11-years. But you can find other boats of similar age without that problem. My personal preference is to buy used Boston Whaler boats that are not big projects. I like to go boating, to enjoy my time on the water, and I do not have the space, the time, or the inclination to undertake major restoration projects.