Colaboks wrote:I have narrowed my propeller choice to an ENERTIA 18 pitch.
[Give your] thoughts [about selecting an ENERTIA 18 pitch for the OMC 150 and OUTRAGE 18].
The ENERTIA propeller was developed for extra speed. The principal feature of the ENERTIA is that the boat speed will improve at full throttle because the propeller will be turned 200-RPM faster than other propellers of the same pitch rating. How this is achieved is not explained, except that the propeller material is some form of Unobtainium™, and the propeller blades are made very thin. The thin blades are probably the biggest influence on the improved boat speed. The Unobtainium™ metal is said to be sufficiently strong to be workable with the thinner blades, and it also is said to flex. This is a conundrum because usually flexing propeller blades are considered a deficit not an asset.
Perhaps the real attribute of the ENERTIA is that the propeller is sold in pitch increments of only 1-inch. This may be the real key to getting the extra 200-RPM out of the engine and a boost in top boat speed: the propeller pitch can be selected to put the full-throttle engine speed right into the perfect range for optimum power output, where a 2-inch pitch change might overshoot or undershoot the desired engine speed at maximum throttle. And the ENERTIA was developed in the early days of the VERADO and other four-stroke-power-cycle engines which generally need to be able to accelerate to the very top of their allowed engine speed range to produce maximum power. A c.1996 OMC two-stroke engine most likely will actually produce its peak power output below the maximum allowed engine speed by several hundred RPM.
Also, you remarked initially:
Colaboks wrote:I do not need to break the 50-MPH; top speed is of no priority to me.
In the context of that statement , an ENERTIA seems to conflict with your stated goals.
As PHIL T notes, the price tag on the ENERTIA propellers is probably about double many other choices. There are many used OMC SST 17 propellers around that would cost about $150 if in very good to excellent condition.
Now, all that said, I would sea trial and test an ENERTIA on my engine if I did not have to buy a $700 propeller and have no option to return it for full refund if the test was not impressive. I would like to test the ENERTIA just to see what outcome would occur. (And I would also like to test the totally different ENERTIA ECO propeller, which was developed specifically to boost fuel economy with the supercharged VERADO engines, but that is another story and another thread.)
Here is a comment about the ENERTIA
posted in December 2005 by a fellow who worked in the propeller division of Mercury Marine, right after the ENERTIA was announced:
I happen to work in the propeller division at Mercury Marine. I would like to try and answer some of the topics brought up here regarding the new ENERTIA propellers.
- The suggested retail price for the ENERTIA will be $646.
- The new X7 alloy is 30% stronger and four-times more durable. This allows us to cast the propeller with thinner blades. Thinner blades means less resistance, less resistance means greater performance--without sacrificing durability.
- We are a member of the National Marine Propeller Association, and we have sent several of our early prototype X7 ENERTIA propellers to various members to perform welding tests and various types of repairs. The response we received was that they are not that much different to work with than conventional stainless propellers. Thus I would guess that any type of repairs that you might need would be relative to what you might pay currently for a conventional stainless propeller repair.
- These propellers have been tested and still are being tested on a variety of applications and conditions, which is part of the reason the propellers will not be available until the second quarter.
- The HP claims are based upon the fact that we gained 2-MPH top end speed during our testing. If you compare that increase in speed to HP it results in 17 HP gain.
- The testing results that you see in a lot of the Enertia promotional material are using a MIRAGE propeller as a baseline.
- We have found that the ENERTIA propellers tend to turn another 200 to 300 RPM pitch-for-pitch which should prove to be beneficial on the newer higher-horsepower four-stroke engines.
- Additionally we are offering the propellers in 1-inch pitch increments to help dial in the appropriate WOT range of the a lot of the higher horsepower four -stroke outboards.
Those comments solicited several follow-on questions, but the contributor did not respond in the forum nor did he respond to direct email inquiries.